Attorneys
Worcester
Worcester
The Guaranty Building
370 Main Street, 12th Floor
Worcester, MA 01608
Framingham
Framingham
The Meadows
161 Worcester Road, Suite 501
Framingham, MA 01701
Boston
Boston
12 Post Office Square, 6th Floor
Boston, MA 02109
Providence
Providence
1 Richmond Square, Suite 303N
Providence, RI 02906
Cape Cod
Cape Cod
1597 Falmouth Road
Centerville, MA 02632
Hudson
Hudson
69 Main Street
Hudson, MA 01749
New Bedford
New Bedford
651 Orchard Street, Suite 107
New Bedford, MA 02744
Medfield
Medfield
Olde Medfield Square
266 Main Street, Bldg. 2, Suite 15A
Medfield, MA 02052
Practice Areas
Niche industries
Open detail
Cannabis & Breweries
Cannabis & Breweries
Open detail
Closely Held and Family-Owned Businesses
Closely Held and Family-Owned Businesses
Open detail
Condominiums
Condominiums
Open detail
Medical & Dental Practices
Medical & Dental Practices
Open detail
Private Foundations
Private Foundations
Open detail
Real Estate Developers
Real Estate Developers
Open detail
Restaurants
Restaurants
Open detail
All Industries
  • Wed. Oct. 28, 2020
  • 6:00-8:00 PM
 

Government Benefits to fund Housing for Persons with Disabilities

Take a deep dive into learning about Government Benefits that provide residential supports.

Learn More

Learn MoreClick here to Register
  • Multiple Dates

Estate Planning Webinar

Please join Fletcher Tilton Tax Attorney and Certified Elder Law Attorney Michael T. Lahti for an informative webinar. In the comfort of your own home or office, you will learn why some wills do not work, even when drafted correctly.  Details for the next upcoming date.

SHOW ALL UPCOMING DATES

Learn More
Learn More
  • Multiple Dates

How to Administer a Special Needs Trust

This annual training and update for Parents, Trustees and Successor Trustees of Special Needs Trusts and OBRA ‘93 Trusts has been reconfigured into a three-part series of evening webinars to accommodate these unusual times.  Details for the next upcoming date.

SHOW ALL UPCOMING DATES

Learn More
Learn More
Learn More
  • Tue. Nov. 17, 2020
  • 6:00-7:00 PM
 

Thrive Support & Advocacy Virtual Workshop

Fletcher Tilton attorney Theresa Varnet, M.S.W., J.D. will speak about ABLE Accounts with 1st and 3rd Party Special Needs Trusts.

Learn More

Learn More

View Past Seminars

Articles

When Your Insurer Issues a Reservation of Rights: Why You Should Choose Your Own Lawyer

By Adam C. Ponte on July 29, 2019

You or your business is served with a lawsuit. It could be for a slip-and-fall, construction defect or even wrongful death. In any event, you paid those hefty insurance premiums for this very moment – right? After receiving the plaintiff ’s Complaint, you likely send it to your insurance agent or your carrier. In the next week or so, the insurer could (i) agree that the claim is fully covered and agree to defend you; (ii) notify you that the claim is not covered, at all; or (iii) reserve its right to disclaim coverage, but provide you with a legal defense (at least for the time being).

Under the last scenario, the insurer will send you a letter telling you all of the reasons why your insurance policy may not cover the plaintiff ’s claims. This letter, also known as the insurer’s Reservation of Rights, is the insurer’s message, to you, that it is reserving the right to disclaim coverage. In the meantime, the insurer undertakes your defense by providing you with a lawyer. Yes, the insurer would be paying your legal fees, but significant conflicts could arise between you and the insurer. That is, the insurer could contend that the loss, or a portion of the loss, is not covered under the policy. You, on the other hand, want the entire loss covered. This awkward situation could cause the insurance defense lawyer to defend your case in a manner that better suits the insurer, perhaps winning against the plaintiff on the covered claims and losing on the non- covered claims. Under this scenario, although the insurer may have footed the legal bill, the insured would pay the plaintiff for the non-covered damages, and the insurer would have no further liability. Additionally, a lawyer frequently hired by the same insurer will have an incentive to please the insurer, not the insured. There is nothing like a steady stream of business.

Under a Reservation of Rights, the insured must be wary of the possibility that the insurer-provided attorney may favor the insurer over the insured in the course of litigation. The good news for insureds in Massachusetts is that you may be entitled to choose your lawyer, with the insurer paying the bill. Therefore, when the insurer issues a Reservation of Rights, you should choose your own lawyer.

Standard General Liability Policies and Massachusetts Law

Standard general liability policies provide that the insurer will (i) defend the insured against claims, including attorney’s fees; and (ii) pay damages for which the insured is held liable. This is known as the insurers “duty to defend” and “duty to indemnify.” Of course, the insurer narrows its duty to defend and/or indemnify only to policy-covered claims.

We will pay those sums that the insured becomes legally obligated to pay as damages because of “bodily injury” or “property damage” to which this insurance applies. We will have the right and duty to defend the insured against any “suit” seeking those damages. However, we will have no duty to defend the insured against any “suit” seeking damages for “bodily injury” or “property damage” to which this insurance does not apply. ISO Form CG 00 01, Section I (1)(a).

Generally, an insurer’s duty to defend is broader than its duty to indemnify the insured. See Boston Symphony Orchestra v. Commercial Union Ins. Co., 406 Mass. 7, 10 (1989) (“It is axiomatic that an insurance company’s duty to defend is broader than its duty to indemnify … the duty to defend is based on the facts alleged in the complaint and those facts which are known by the insurer”); Doe v. Liberty Mut. Ins. Co., 423 Mass. 366, 368-69 (1996).

Accordingly, if the plaintiff ’s complaint against the insured contains multiple claims, only one of which is covered by the policy, the insurer likely remains obligated to defend the entire action, including the non-covered claim. Aetna Cas. & Sur. Co. v. Cont’l Cas. Co., 413 Mass. 730, 732 n. 1 (1992) (“[T]he weight of authority places the duty to defend all counts on an insurer which has a duty to defend at least one count of a complaint, barring a contrary agreement with the insured”); Herbert A. Sullivan, Inc. v. Utica Mut. Ins. Co., 439 Mass. 387, 394 (2003) (“[I]f the allegations of the complaint are reasonably susceptible of an interpretation that they state or adumbrate a claim covered by the policy terms, the insurer must undertake the defense.”).

The Insurer’s Reservation of Rights Creates the Insured’s Right to Choose Counsel

In the scenario where some of the plaintiff ’s claims arguably are not covered, the insurer is required to notify the insured of such potential lack of coverage. See DiMarzo v. Am. Mut. Ins. Co., 389 Mass. 85, 112 (1983); Salonen v. Paanenen, 320 Mass. 568, 573 (1947) (“Where an insurer seasonably notifies its insured that it is continuing to defend the case subject to its right to disclaim later, the insured is in no position to say that he has been misled, and can take the necessary steps to protect his rights”); Three Sons, Inc. v. Phoenix Ins. Co., 357 Mass. 271, 276 (1970) (“A reservation of rights ... notifies the insured that the insurer’s defense is subject to the later right to disclaim liability.”).

Hence, after the insured notifies the insurer of the claims, the insurer likely will send the Reservation of Rights to the insured. Upon receiving the Reservation of Rights, you, the insured, now have the right to select your lawyer. See Magoun v. Liberty Mut. Ins. Co., 346 Mass. 677, 684 (1964) (“Where the insured’s interest in controlling tort litigation against him conflicts with the similar interest of the insurer, the insured may have good cause to ask that he be represented by counsel independent of the insurer”); Herbert A. Sullivan, Inc. v. Utica Mut. Ins. Co., 439 Mass. 387, 407 (2003) (“[T]he insured may require the insurer either to relinquish its reservation of rights or relinquish its defense of the insured and reimburse the insured for its defense costs.”).

Forcing the insurer to allow you to select counsel certainly is in your best interest. An attorney hired by the insurer likely will not represent you with an eye toward maximizing coverage of the claims asserted against you. In fact, insurance defense counsel probably cannot assist you with coverage-related issues, because he or she would be representing both you and the insurer. Increasing the insured’s chances for maximum coverage would run afoul of that same attorney’s obligation to the insurer. Thus, you should choose your own counsel, who not only will defend the claims against you, but also will keep tabs on maximizing coverage – all while the insurer pays the bill.

Make Sure to Assert The Right to Choose Counsel Properly

If you receive an insurer’s Reservation of Rights, you should immediately contact your attorney so that he or she can begin to create a record establishing coverage of the claims and to preserve your right to demand your own counsel. Your attorney should promptly send a letter to the insurer, opposing the Reservation of Rights and stating the insured’s intention to engage an independent attorney, at the insurer’s expense. Indeed, failure to timely oppose the insurer’s selection of counsel could prohibit the insured’s right to seek his or her own attorney. See Herbert A. Sullivan, Inc. v. Utica Mut. Ins. Co., 439 Mass. 387, 407 (2003) (“There is no indication in the record that [insured] either insisted on having the reservation of rights removed or, in the alternative, insisted on assuming control of its own defense … [a]s such, we conclude that [insured] acquiesced in the legal representation provided by [insurer].”).

Of course, by opposing the Reservation of Rights and demanding your own attorney, this could compel the insurer to drop its reservation to disclaim coverage and accept full coverage of the claim. To that end, the insurer essentially would indemnify the insured up to the policy limits.

Conclusion

If your insurer reserves its right to disclaim coverage via a Reservation of Rights, it is imperative that you oppose such reservation and notify your insurer of your intent to select independent counsel to represent you. Your attorney will defend the actual claim and keep an eye toward preserving insurance coverage. Do not let the insurer control the defense of the claim against you if the insurer will not commit to full coverage.

Please enter your name.
Please enter your email address.
Please enter your message.

You must attach a copy of the PDF application form linked above. You may add pages to the application, but the name of the file must remain the same.

Please attach Job_Application_Form.pdf
reCAPTCHA is mandatory
Subscribe to our newsletter.
First name is required.
Email is required.
Email does not match.
Publications
reCAPTCHA is mandatory
Welcome to fletcher tilton Online Invoice Payment Center.
Card holders name is required.
Please enter invoice number.
Please enter amount to be paid.
Please enter valid card number.
CCV code is required.
/
Please select expiration date.
Please enter your street address.
Please enter your city.
Please enter your state Code.
Please enter your postal code.
Please enter your contact number.
Please enter your email address.
Welcome to fletcher tilton Online Retainer Funding Center.
Card holders name is required.
Please enter a client number.
Please enter amount to be paid.
Please enter valid card number.
CCV code is required.
/
Please select expiration date.
Please enter your street address.
Please enter your city.
Please enter your state Code.
Please enter your postal code.
Please enter your contact number.
Please enter your email address.
Welcome to fletcher tilton Online Immigration Pre-Payment Center.
Bank account type is required.
Please enter a valid name.
Please enter amount to be paid.
Please enter client number.
Bank routing number is required.
Bank routing did not match.
Bank account number is required.
Bank account number did not match.
Please enter your street address.
Please enter your city.
Please enter your state Code.
Please enter your postal code.
Please enter your contact number.
Please enter your email address.
Welcome to fletcher tilton Online PAY BY CHECK.
Bank account type is required.
Please enter a valid name.
Please enter amount to be paid.
Please enter invoice number.
Bank routing number is required.
Bank routing did not match.
Bank account number is required.
Bank account number did not match.
Please enter your street address.
Please enter your city.
Please enter your state Code.
Please enter your postal code.
Please enter your contact number.
Please enter your email address.