Trial Update | DeVico v. Sullivan (Barnstable Superior Court)
Fletcher Tilton is pleased to share a successful trial outcome in DeVico v. Sullivan, litigated in Barnstable Superior Court. Attorney Patrick Tinsley represented Ms. Sullivan, who was named as a defendant in a lawsuit brought by two of her brothers concerning ownership of their parents’ former home.
In 2006, the defendant’s parents deeded their house to her alone, reflecting their intention that she own the property exclusively. Years later—after Ms. Sullivan placed the home into her personal trust—the brothers filed suit, alleging breach of fiduciary duty and fraud, and claiming that their parents intended the property to be shared equally among the siblings.
At trial, the defense presented compelling testimony, including from Ms. Sullivan and the estate planning attorney who prepared the parents’ wills and related documents. The attorney—the sole non-party witness—confirmed that the parents’ clear intent was for Ms. Sullivan to have sole ownership of the home. During cross-examination, the plaintiffs admitted on the stand that they had not, in fact, heard their father say the house was to be shared equally. Ms. Sullivan testified credibly and sincerely, reinforcing the documentary and testimonial evidence supporting her position.
This outcome reflects a strong, team-driven effort. A sincere thank you to attorneys Adam Balderelli, Nisha Koshy, and Elisabeth Finn for their outstanding support at every stage of the litigation, including summary judgment, the interlocutory appeal, trial pleadings, and research. Their contributions were critical to this result.
Congratulations to Patrick and the entire team on an excellent trial presentation and result for our client.