Attorneys
Worcester
Worcester
The Guaranty Building
370 Main Street, 12th Floor
Worcester, MA 01608
Framingham
Framingham
The Meadows
161 Worcester Road, Suite 501
Framingham, MA 01701
Boston
Boston
12 Post Office Square, 6th Floor
Boston, MA 02109
Providence
Providence
1 Richmond Square, Suite 303N
Providence, RI 02906
Cape Cod
Cape Cod
1597 Falmouth Road
Centerville, MA 02632
Hudson
Hudson
69 Main Street
Hudson, MA 01749
New Bedford
New Bedford
651 Orchard Street, Suite 107
New Bedford, MA 02744
Medfield
Medfield
Olde Medfield Square
266 Main Street, Bldg. 2, Suite 15A
Medfield, MA 02052
Practice Areas
Niche industries
Open detail
Cannabis & Breweries
Cannabis & Breweries
Open detail
Closely Held and Family-Owned Businesses
Closely Held and Family-Owned Businesses
Open detail
Condominiums
Condominiums
Open detail
Medical & Dental Practices
Medical & Dental Practices
Open detail
Private Foundations
Private Foundations
Open detail
Real Estate Developers
Real Estate Developers
Open detail
Restaurants
Restaurants
Open detail
All Industries
  • Wed. Oct. 28, 2020
  • 6:00-8:00 PM
 

Government Benefits to fund Housing for Persons with Disabilities

Take a deep dive into learning about Government Benefits that provide residential supports.

Learn More

Learn MoreClick here to Register
  • Multiple Dates

Estate Planning Webinar

Please join Fletcher Tilton Tax Attorney and Certified Elder Law Attorney Michael T. Lahti for an informative webinar. In the comfort of your own home or office, you will learn why some wills do not work, even when drafted correctly.  Details for the next upcoming date.

SHOW ALL UPCOMING DATES

Learn More
Learn More
  • Multiple Dates

How to Administer a Special Needs Trust

This annual training and update for Parents, Trustees and Successor Trustees of Special Needs Trusts and OBRA ‘93 Trusts has been reconfigured into a three-part series of evening webinars to accommodate these unusual times.  Details for the next upcoming date.

SHOW ALL UPCOMING DATES

Learn More
Learn More
Learn More
  • Tue. Nov. 17, 2020
  • 6:00-7:00 PM
 

Thrive Support & Advocacy Virtual Workshop

Fletcher Tilton attorney Theresa Varnet, M.S.W., J.D. will speak about ABLE Accounts with 1st and 3rd Party Special Needs Trusts.

Learn More

Learn More

View Past Seminars

Articles

Any Bargaining Obligations with Unions Over New D.E.S.E. Retell/Certification Requirements?

By Joseph T. Bartulis, Jr. on October 28, 2019

In December 2012, the Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (DESE), Mitchell D. Chester, Ed.D., detailed the new and somewhat extensive RETELL (Rethinking Equity and Teaching for English Language Learners) - Sheltered English Immersion endorsement and the related professional development requirements. The endorsement and PDP requirements directly impact affected teachers license criteria, and license renewal standards, among other things.

Accordingly, given the impact these new provisions will have on new and incumbent teachers alike, many questions have been posed by school district administrators across the Commonwealth regarding whether school districts have bargaining obligations with their teachers, be they decisional/main-table contract negotiations, impact bargaining obligations, or neither regarding these new changes?

Without getting into the minutia of the RETELL provisions or any of the precise requirements related thereto, there is little doubt that the RETELL provisions do impact wages, hours and terms and conditions of employment (the mandatory subjects of bargaining) of teachers. That fact, absent more, would generally be understood to require bargaining with the union if an employer-school district unilaterally decided to impose these requirements on its own.

That said, reviewing MGL. c.150E (often referred to as the Massachusetts Labor-Management Relations Act) and the decisions decided thereunder the Law is quite clear that employers in the instant matter do not have an obligation to decisional bargain with the union over changes which are mandated by the DESE. This is because decisional bargaining, by implication, presupposes that the change being requested is being sought by the employer and is not being imposed by the Commonwealth. Since that is not the case here there is no decisional bargaining obligation.

Next, the question becomes whether there is an obligation for Massachusetts school districts to impact bargain with their teachers’ unions regarding the RETELL changes? That decision turns largely on the nature of the change being imposed and whether the impact bargaining obligations, if any, occur under the above-referred statute or under the collective bargaining agreement. As you will recall, the difference between impact bargaining and decisional bargaining is that unlike decisional bargaining -- where the unions agreement is required as a prerequisite for a change to occur -- impact bargaining only obligates the employer to provide the union notice and an opportunity to bargain over the impacts that the decision (which is not open for discussion) will have on the union’s members. Because the decision itself is not open for debate, impact bargaining often focuses on the procedures that will be in place to get from where a district is now to where it will be when the changes are implemented. Whenever there is an impact bargaining obligation, the Law requires that the union receive advance notice of the change before it takes place and an opportunity to impact bargain before the change occurs.

Looking first at whether there is an impact bargaining obligation under MGL c.150E, an argument can be made that there is no bargaining obligation at all since the change does not impact the teachers working conditions per se but rather constitutes a precondition to working at all -- since it relates to one’s license to be employable as a teacher. Stated another way, a school district could argue that their obligation to bargain only extends to those things over which it actually has any control. Here, the districts have no control over either the decision to change the state’s licensure requirements or how they are implemented; hence, they are not obligated to bargain. While it is probable that there is no bargaining obligation whatsoever, districts that want to completely immunize themselves from any potential unfair labor practice charge regarding an alleged impact bargaining obligation may nonetheless wish to give the union notice of the RETELL “change” (which the union likely already knows about anyway) and offer to meet with them to discuss the impacts of that “change.” Having met with the union and having allowed them to convey any concerns they have may go a long way to engendering good labor relations and will better insulate the district from an avoidable unfair labor practice charge.

Finally, regarding whether school districts are obligated to bargain over these changes pursuant to a provision in the collective bargaining agreement, that question cannot be answered herein. While I presume that most collective bargaining agreements will not contain language which creates additional bargaining obligations, districts will want to thoroughly review their collective bargaining agreement to be certain. Whether there are any bargaining obligations under the statute or collective bargaining agreement in a particular district should be determined by conversation with your district’s legal counsel.

Please enter your name.
Please enter your email address.
Please enter your message.

You must attach a copy of the PDF application form linked above. You may add pages to the application, but the name of the file must remain the same.

Please attach Job_Application_Form.pdf
reCAPTCHA is mandatory
Subscribe to our newsletter.
First name is required.
Email is required.
Email does not match.
Publications
reCAPTCHA is mandatory
Welcome to fletcher tilton Online Invoice Payment Center.
Card holders name is required.
Please enter invoice number.
Please enter amount to be paid.
Please enter valid card number.
CCV code is required.
/
Please select expiration date.
Please enter your street address.
Please enter your city.
Please enter your state Code.
Please enter your postal code.
Please enter your contact number.
Please enter your email address.
Welcome to fletcher tilton Online Retainer Funding Center.
Card holders name is required.
Please enter a client number.
Please enter amount to be paid.
Please enter valid card number.
CCV code is required.
/
Please select expiration date.
Please enter your street address.
Please enter your city.
Please enter your state Code.
Please enter your postal code.
Please enter your contact number.
Please enter your email address.
Welcome to fletcher tilton Online Immigration Pre-Payment Center.
Bank account type is required.
Please enter a valid name.
Please enter amount to be paid.
Please enter client number.
Bank routing number is required.
Bank routing did not match.
Bank account number is required.
Bank account number did not match.
Please enter your street address.
Please enter your city.
Please enter your state Code.
Please enter your postal code.
Please enter your contact number.
Please enter your email address.
Welcome to fletcher tilton Online PAY BY CHECK.
Bank account type is required.
Please enter a valid name.
Please enter amount to be paid.
Please enter invoice number.
Bank routing number is required.
Bank routing did not match.
Bank account number is required.
Bank account number did not match.
Please enter your street address.
Please enter your city.
Please enter your state Code.
Please enter your postal code.
Please enter your contact number.
Please enter your email address.